The Bay Horse Inn, tucked away in Newcastle, has a really charming, low-key vibe. It’s not flashy, but the space feels warm and inviting; the photos online showed simple wooden furniture and warm lighting, which perfectly captured that feeling. It felt like the kind of place you could easily spend hours chatting over good food and drinks. I immediately felt comfortable there.

Their menu is Caribbean-inspired, with lots of fresh, flavourful dishes. They’ve got classic options alongside some more creative takes on familiar things. I saw a photo of a perfectly plated jerk chicken dish—it looked incredible—and the curried goat was mentioned in high regard by other diners online. I’d definitely recommend checking out their daily specials too; they seemed to change often, keeping the menu feeling exciting.

What makes The Bay Horse Inn special is its relaxed atmosphere and genuinely delicious food. It's perfect for a casual date night, a catch-up with friends, or even a solo dinner. It's different from other Caribbean restaurants I’ve been to because of its understated elegance – it focuses on quality food and a friendly atmosphere rather than loud gimmicks. I think anyone who appreciates good Caribbean food in a laid-back setting would love this place.